Sunday Soup #91: Instant Pot Crack Chicken Spinach Soup

How does the classic literary quote go? "It was the best of soups, it was the worst of soups..." Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's accurate... 😆 Well, whether that's how it goes or not, that might be a good way to describe this past week's Sunday Soup. I wasn't specifically drawn to this one for any particular reason, but it looked yummy and was in the batch of choices I sent to my friend (and frequent dinner guest) Lisa for her to pick through. She picked it, we made it, now I get to review it... Check it out!

This recipe came from: https://www.eatwell101.com/instant-pot-crack-chicken-soup-recipe

*Pic 1 - https://www.eatwell101.com/instant-pot-crack-chicken-soup-recipe

Variations from Recipe as Written: We made 1.5x the recipe. We used regular chicken broth instead of bone broth. And, we added an extra cup of spinach, 1.5 cups of broth, and 1/2-pound of chicken (all because of package sizes).

General Thoughts: The prep (getting the ingredients in the Instant Pot, anyway) was very simple... The entire recipe only called for seven ingredients total, and some light spinach chopping was really the only real prep step required. We had to shred the chicken after it was cooked, but that was also a piece of cake using Lisa's favorite electric hand mixer method (similar to this one: https://food-hacks.wonderhowto.com/how-to/make-shredded-chicken-seconds-with-mixer-0172718/).

But, you may be saying to yourself, "Wait, that picture below does not look like an Instant Pot!" You are correct, Intrepid Reader, that is not an Instant Pot... Within 15 minutes of closing the Instant Pot and starting it on its way to High Pressure, it started flashing a "burning" warning and shut itself off. Hmm... I had never experienced anything like it. Sure enough, when I opened it, some of the chicken breasts appeared to have been starting to burn on the bottom of the pot. However, Lisa and I quickly pivoted and transferred the now-hot soup to a pot on the stove to allow the chicken to finish cooking fully. Thankfully, once we salvaged the Instant Pot situation, the rest of the cooking went off without a hitch!

*Pics 2 & 3 - Pictures from when we made it

It tasted pretty good... It was VERY hearty, creamy, and bacon-y, all of which hit the spot. The cream cheese in the broth made it smooth and delicious, and I found myself wanting more. In fact, that was everyone's biggest comment: it was not nearly brothy enough! It was thick and felt very "heavy" (due to all of the creamy cheese and chicken), feeling more like a dip or a chili than a soup. It makes me wonder how it would taste poured over the top of a baked potato? I am betting, super yummy!

This soup also seemed to be missing enough spice and had a uniformity of flavor that, although tasty overall, made it a little boring. The bacon was a good start but, after that, there wasn't much flavor variation, as the spinach did not really announce itself (we chopped it rather than leaving the baby spinach leaves whole) and the chicken just took on the flavor of the cheese.

In the end, this one seemed like a promising start/base, but I'd definitely want to make some significant changes if I made it again.

Potential Improvements? My suggested changes for this one are numerous and were supported by almost all of my guests for this one... First, it needed more spice and something to diversify the flavor profile; I think I'd like to try adding a can of Ro-tel Diced Tomatoes with Chiles (they make them with Green Chiles, Chipotle Peppers, Serrano Peppers, and Habanero Peppers, so pick your poison!) to provide both taste and texture upgrades. Next, it definitely needs more broth and probably had too much chicken. So, looking at the original recipe, I'd likely double the amount of broth (to 3 cups) and reduce the amount of chicken by 1/4-to-1/2 a pound overall. Finally, I'd probably increase the amount of spinach by at least another cup.

Polling the Fam: I thought it was tasty and that it had good potential, but if I make it again I'll make all the changes noted above. Becky thought it needed more broth, less chicken, and more spice, but she also thought it was a good base. Jayson echoed that it was tasty but needed more broth and spice. And, Lisa thought more broth, less chicken, less bacon (heresy!), more spinach, and adding some onions would be the winning combo.

Verdict: It was okay. (3 stars)