Sunday Soup #90: Basler Mehlsuppe (Basel Flour Soup)

This week, I learned that I am headed to teach a class in Switzerland early next year... So, naturally, I started researching Swiss food! There were plenty of references to fondue and sausage, of course, but I was surprised to find that Switzerland has quite a soup culture, as well.

A classic Swiss soup, traditionally served around Fasnacht (better known to English speakers as Carnivál or Fat Tuesday, marking the start of the Lenten season), is called Basler Mehlsuppe (or, Basel Flour Soup). In the city of Basel, in particular, they host a Carnivál parade at 4 a.m. on a Monday before Lent (usually in February or March), and the Mehlsuppe is eaten in the morning after the parade. There are several versions of the origins of this particular tradition, but the website https://www.helvetickitchen.com/recipes/2016/2/15/baslermehlsuppe presents this version: "The most common origin story involves a chatty cook who burnt the flour for the soup during preparation. Instead of starting again, the mistake was added to the dish and met with great success."

Although it is currently November, I'll be headed to Switzerland around Lent next year, so I thought this would be an interesting recipe to try. :-)

This recipe came from: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/13219/basler-mehlsuppa/

Variations from Recipe as Written: None.

General Thoughts: This soup was extremely easy to prepare and inexpensive to make, requiring only eight ingredients (most of which I - and probably you - regularly keep in the pantry). Slicing one onion, shredding a bit of cheese, and toasting the flour was really all it took! As written, the recipe seemed to make about four servings, so you may need to double or triple it if making for a crowd.

*Pics 1-4 - Pictures from when we made it

This soup was interesting in that, despite the simple ingredients, there were a lot of different tastes (and textures) going on. The toasted flour was the real star, adding a rich, comforting taste that was fairly unique. The gruyere was also important as it added some saltiness and creaminess to the soup. I could definitely taste the red wine but found myself wishing that flavor was even a bit stronger. Sadly, the overall taste profile was a little bland, but that could be helped by being a bit more aggressive with the salt, pepper, and wine.

The texture was also a little odd... The thick wheat bread the recipe called for at the bottom of each bowl was alternately mushy and firm/spongy, as well as having some whole grains that made it "feel" and taste a little nutty.

I think this one is a bit better suited to being a side dish than a main course, particularly since it did not contain any protein. And, in the end, other than the unique toasted flour, there seemed to be little difference between this recipe and a middle-of-the-road French onion soup.

Potential Improvements? There was quite a bit to improve on with this one, in my opinion... If I make it again, I will likely swap out the wheat bread for a slice of sourdough. In addition, some more salt and pepper, a bit of rosemary or thyme, and a couple of extra splashes of red wine would serve to give the dish some additional flavor.

Polling the Fam: I thought it was not bad, overall, but I'd probably not make it again except as a side dish or for a theme meal, and then only with my above-noted changes. Becky was turned off by the nutty taste and odd texture of the wheat bread. And, Fox said he really didn't care for it, also primarily due to the bread.

Verdict: Not a fan. (2 stars)