Sunday Soup #123: Big Red Soup

I love being (pleasantly) surprised by a recipe... Last week was New Year's, and I was riding high on the dual joys of leaving 2020 behind and the start of the College Football Bowl Season! When pondering football food, I wondered if there were any "football soups" that looked tasty. I figured, Why not? Football is played in Winter... Soups are eaten in Winter... And, football fans like to eat!

I soon stumbled across this recipe called "Big Red Soup," named after the author's favorite College Football team, the Nebraska Cornhuskers (affectionately known to their fans as "Big Red"). The prep looked pretty straightforward, and the author said her "... whole family gathers around the television set to eat it while watching the game," so I figured it was worth a try. Let's see how it went...

This recipe came from: https://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/big-red-soup/

*Pic 1 - https://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/big-red-soup/

Variations from the Recipe as Written: I followed the recipe as written.

General Thoughts: The prep looked easy, and it was! I used stew meat that came already cubed from the store, and my wife chopped the onion for me (I cry like a baby when I do it, and she takes pity on me), so all I had to do was brown the meat. My family also likes its tortillas "cooked" in the pan, so that took a few minutes toward the end, but the slow cooker did all the real work in this one! If you were hosting a party and looking for an easy soup to prep in bulk and throw into multiple slow cookers (or a huge soup pot to slow simmer on the stove), this would be a great choice. 

*Pics 2 & 3 - Pictures from when I made it

At the top, I alluded to this recipe being a surprise because it didn't start off very well, despite the easy prep. Once I got everything together in the slow cooker and started it cooking, I was concerned on more than one front... Giving it a stir, it was very brothy; with no starchy ingredients (e.g., potatoes, beans, etc.) and few vegetables, it didn't seem like it would have nearly enough bulk.  I definitely worried that it would not be hearty or satisfying enough to serve as a meal on its own. And, while I had browned the meat in oil, and stew meat is not the leanest beef cut around, it didn't look like it would have enough fat to compensate for the lack of bulk or give the broth the proper "mouthfeel". Finally, the author said the soup was meant to have a Mexican flavor, and it looked to be shaping up like any one of the seemingly-hundreds of generic "taco soup" recipes out there, which I despise because they all taste the same. However, I am happy to say that the finished product put all my worries to rest!

When the soup was finished, I garnished it with quartered corn tortillas in the bottom of the bowl and a nice layer of cheese on top, and it definitely delivered. The flavor was Mexican overall (as the author had promised), but it was not overpowering and did not taste like a generic taco soup to me. I was able to pick out the subtle tastes of cumin, Worcestershire sauce, and lemon pepper seasoning in the rich tomato-y broth, and I was surprised by how layered and complex the flavor turned out to be. Further, when melted and stirred in, the cheese provided both the "thickness" and fat the broth may have been lacking on its own, helping strike the perfect balance between too brothy and too stew-like. The tortillas, likewise, were a terrific starchy addition to the soup, adding their own interesting texture profile. The beef was super tender and picked up the flavor of the soup nicely. I also tried a bowl with a dollop of sour cream, which was pleasant but ultimately unnecessary. You could also add some freshly squeezed lime to your bowl if you wanted to cut the fat from the cheese a bit more, but I really didn't feel like it needed it.

Potential Improvements? Although this one turned out very well, I might like to add some Mexican hominy to the pot in the future.

Polling the Fam: I really liked this one and found myself craving it the next day. I definitely would like to make it again and see if it really will satisfy a larger crowd! Hunter really enjoyed it, too, and... brace yourself... Fox said, "It was not bad, better than okay, and I liked the taste, especially with cheese. We should make this one for the Stebbinses." I'll take that as my blue ribbon for the week! :-)

Verdict: Loved it! (5 stars)

Sunday Soup #122: The 30-Minute Best Creamy White Bean chicken Chili

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays!! As we go cruising into Christmas Week, the weather outside is frightful, and the fire is so delightful... So, don't we deserve a soup to match? I think so!

My mother-in-law arrived Sunday, so I went looking for a soup I thought she'd like. I've made several white bean soups in the past, and some (like #22, #83, and #89) have been close to amazing, so I felt pretty good about this recipe. The pictures looked yummy, it seemed fairly easy to prepare, and (most importantly) everything in it agreed with everyone's palate. So, how did it come out?

This recipe came from: https://www.savorybitesrecipes.com/2019/11/creamy-white-bean-chicken-chili.html

*Pic 1 - https://www.savorybitesrecipes.com/2019/11/creamy-white-bean-chicken-chili.html

Variations from Recipe as Written: This recipe, as written, claimed to make only 3 servings(?!), and I was worried about having enough, so I tripled the recipe. Tripled, the recipe fed five people with enough leftovers for 3 or so more bowls. And, I used regular chicken broth (instead of low sodium or unsalted broth), but then did not add any salt to the pot.

General Thoughts: As I suspected, this recipe did turn out to be fairly easy to prep. But, this was one of those recipes that is a little "fuzzy" in places; meaning, rather than providing exact measurements or directions, it was sometimes vague or not very specific. As one example, a step tells the cook to add the green chilis and "sauté further." Really? "Further"? Does that mean 3 minutes or 15 minutes? I know, I know... a seasoned cook can roll with it, and it didn't cause me much trouble. But, it bugs me when a chef provides a recipe they created but doesn't share their vision for how it should be prepared. How do I know I am eating the version of the recipe the chef envisioned? But, I digress...

*Pics 2 & 3 - Pictures from when I made it

The soup was much brothier than I expected, which is not always a bad thing... But, I expected a chili to be a little thicker. There were definitely not enough beans, and I got more than a few spoonfuls out of my bowl with no beans at all. The texture was fine, overall, offering enough variety to be interesting, and the chicken was tender and flavorful. But, being that the chicken and beans were the only real bulk in this soup, it wasn't very hearty and left me feeling a bit underwhelmed.

The taste was fine but, again, a little lacking. It did turn out fairly spicy; I used 2/3 mild green chilis and 1/3 hot green chilis, which, when combined with the prescribed amount of cayenne pepper, was perfect for me but overwhelmed my diners with a lower spice tolerance. Beyond that, it didn't really have any other flavors that stood out. It wasn't very salty, it didn't taste strongly of green chilis, and none of the other spices (e.g., oregano, cumin, etc.) really shone through. Despite calling for some lime juice to be added to the pot, and adding more via a lime wedge squeezed into my bowl, I still felt it lacked enough acidic bite to adequately cut through the cream and oil/fat.

Potential Improvements? If I make this one again, I need to cut the spice a little bit to appeal to the masses. I would double the lime juice to cut the cream and fat a bit more. And, I would definitely double the beans.

Polling the Fam: I found this one to be fine, but pretty unremarkable, overall. I would definitely eat it if someone served it to me, and I plan to eat the leftovers, but I'm not sure I'd ever look forward to it, and definitely not without the changes I suggested above. Hunter's opinion pretty much mirrored mine. It was a bit too spicy for Debby, and she thought it needed more beans, but she liked the texture. And, it was too spicy for Fox to eat more than a little bit, but he enjoyed the bread I served with it. :-)

Verdict: It was okay. (3 stars)

Sunday Soup #121: Pasta e Fagioli

Happy holidays, my friends! I hope everyone is staying safe and healthy, anticipating a joyful holiday, and eating lots of soup!!

Last month (October), during our RV tour through some of the prettiest National Parks the Southwest has to offer, we were lucky enough to get to see our family friends, The Perrys, who had recently moved to north of Phoenix, AZ. Nicole was kind enough to make us dinner, which featured the best Pasta e Fagioli soup I have ever had, and I asked her for the recipe so I could share it with you. It always makes me a little nervous to make a dish that someone else served me that I really enjoyed because I worry that I won't be able to do it justice. But, Nicole assured me that the recipe was super solid, and she was sure I could make it taste just as good hers. Let's see how I did...

This recipe came from: https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/giada-de-laurentiis/pasta-e-fagioli-recipe-1943219?_branch_match_id=863791368531524344

*Pic 1 - https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/giada-de-laurentiis/pasta-e-fagioli-recipe-1943219?_branch_match_id=863791368531524344

Variations from Recipe as Written: I used an extra 1/2-cup of diced onions and an extra 2 ounces of pancetta, both because of the sizes that were available at the grocery store. I also used regular chicken broth, rather than low-sodium, because it was what I had on hand. That's it!

General Thoughts: This was one of those soups that was relatively inexpensive, which is always great if you are serving a crowd. To make it even more economical, subbing bacon for the pancetta would help your dollar go even further. And, the prep was fast and easy, which is always a plus... It took me longer to take snippings from my garden rosemary and thyme bushes and tie them up in a cheesecloth bundle with the other herbs than it did to prep anything else. Really! 

*Pics 2 & 3 - Pictures from when I made it

The soup came out brothy, which I really liked, but it didn't seem to have much bulk at first glance, which worried me a little. I mean, there were really only four ingredients to provide any substance: beans, macaroni, pancetta, and onion. However, despite its brothy appearance, the soup was still plenty hearty, with enough bulk to make my tummy feel warm and full. The texture of the beans wasn't exactly right, though, as they were just a little too firm and starchy for my liking. That could have been a result of the brand of kidney beans I used (or maybe they needed to be cooked longer?) because I don't remember the same texture issues when Nicole made it for us.

I really, really liked the taste of this one... It had a perfect amount of salt and pepper, and just the right amounts of garlic and crushed red pepper to give it a little bit of spice. Beyond that, the taste of fresh herbs suffused every bite and made it a joy to eat! Each of the herbs (rosemary, thyme, and bay) did its part and added its own unique, subtle flavor to the soup. And, finishing off each bowl with grated parmesan and a drizzle of olive oil made it all the better.

Potential Improvements? I'd love to try two things with this one the next time I make it... First, I'd really enjoy some more meat (specifically, bacon), which I think would add to both the taste and flavor. Second, I'd like to try using a smaller, more delicate bean, like cannellini (or white) beans.

Polling the Fam: I really enjoyed this one and would definitely make it again (thank you for introducing me to it, Nicole!), especially with the improvements above. Becky was not as sold, saying it was okay and that she'd eat it again, but she had a texture issue with the kidney beans and the pasta together. Hunter, like me, really enjoyed it and said it had nothing in it he didn't like. And, Fox said... wait for it... it was "okay". *sigh*

Verdict: Liked it. (4 stars)

Sunday Soup #120: Scallop & Shrimp Soup

Last week, I stumbled across a podcast on which the guest was a chef who professed to love soup! "I'm listening...." And, when he started talking about using seafood in soups, he had my full attention. It can be tough sometimes to keep seafood (e.g., shellfish or whitefish) from turning to mush in a soup while still being able to tease out the perfect level of rich seafood flavor. The chef went on to talk about how his favorite seafood protein with which to cook was scallops, which, if done right, can be light, tender, and buttery. "What luck," I thought, "I already have a bag of scallops in the freezer I've been waiting to use!" So, I decided to seek out a scallop soup for the week...

I wanted a brothy seafood soup, rather than a chowder, stew, or bisque. It is November, but I live in California, so the weather hasn't yet turned to the point where I'm looking for thicker soups to take the edge off the cold. Enter this recipe from The Nutrition Adventure site, which seemed to fit exactly what I had been looking for: a well-spiced, brothy seafood soup that featured scallops as a main protein. Let's see how it went...

This recipe came from: https://thenutritionadventure.com/scallop-shrimp-soup-2/

*Pic 1 - https://thenutritionadventure.com/scallop-shrimp-soup-2/

Variations from the Recipe as Written: I used Hungarian Hot Paprika because it was what I had on hand. I used 1-tsp of Old Bay instead of 1/2-tsp. I added a little extra garlic. And, I put the diced peppers right in to sauté with the potatoes, onions, and garlic because... uh... I wasn't paying close enough attention (which my sons would laugh at since I always preach attention-to-detail at them). :-)

General Thoughts: The prep for this one wasn't too bad at all! I used frozen scallops and (raw but shelled/deveined) shrimp, so they just needed to be thawed. Thaw shellfish in the refrigerator if you have the time, or float the bags in lukewarm water to thaw them faster (if you plan to use them in short order). I also used pre-diced onion and bell peppers from my local market. After cutting the seafood a little smaller and tossing it in paprika and Old Bay, all that was left was a little chopping on the potatoes, and I was ready to start cooking. This one really was pretty quick and easy!

*Pics 2 & 3 - Pictures from when I made it

The consistency and "weight" of this soup turned out to be exactly what I was looking for. The broth was light and creamy and really served to support and highlight the other ingredients. The textures were terrific, as well, as the scallops and shrimp were perfectly done (meaty and well-cooked but not mushy), and the peppers, onions, and potatoes were all tender and practically melted in my mouth.

In short, the taste was terrific, rich and flavorful, and would definitely appeal to a wide range of palates (so long as your diners enjoy seafood). The soup had a solid seafood flavor overall (as you might expect from a soup whose main ingredients include shellfish), but it was not overpowering. If you prefer an even stronger seafood profile, try substituting seafood broth for the vegetable broth in the recipe. Likewise, the spices in the soup were present and forward but would not overpower more sensitive eaters. They were just a little too subtle for me, personally, but it was nothing a little Cajun seasoning (I like Tony Chachere's Creole Seasoning Mix, myself), a dash of Tabasco, or even some extra Old Bay in my bowl couldn't fix. Finally, the scallops (as I had hoped) were the real star of the dish, turning out sweet and buttery.

A quick word about how far this recipe stretched... There were just two of us eating this soup, and it looked like I had made plenty, but it was so good that we ate the entire pot... We were both definitely quite full afterward, but we just couldn't stop eating! :-) I am not sure if that says more about us or the soup, but consider doubling the recipe if making for a crowd.

Potential Improvements? This one was great as-is, but I might add a little more Old Bay and a few shakes of crushed red pepper the next time I make it for guests that can handle a little more heat.

Polling the Fam: It was just Hunter and me for this one... I really, really liked it and would not hesitate to make it again if I were craving an easy seafood soup with great flavor. Hunter shared that sentiment, saying he really loved the scallops and that he really enjoyed it (after adding a little extra Old Bay to his bowl). As a side note, my seafood-loving friend Jayson would have gone crazy for this soup if he had gotten to try it; next time, buddy!

Verdict: Loved it! (5 stars)

Sunday Soup #119: Green Chile and Garbanzo Bean Stew

My wife and I recently took a road trip through the American Southwest, checking out some of our beautiful national parks, such as Bryce Canyon, Zion, Grand Canyon, and Joshua Tree, as well as places like Sedona. Their beauty was truly something to behold! And, it was on this trip (in one of the National Park gift shops, actually) that I found a book about slow cooking in Southwestern cuisine. The book has a lot of different, yummy-looking soup recipes, and you'll likely be seeing some of them (or my versions of some of them) in the future, but I was particularly inspired by a recipe that incorporated green chiles and garbanzo beans (or chickpeas if ya nasty!). I made more than enough tweaks to the original to make this recipe my own, I think, but I also encourage you to grab the book for yourself if you want to try the original.

This recipe came from: My full recipe, with all of my own takes on things, is below. But the recipe that inspired me came from Southwest Slow Cooking (2004), which you can buy on Amazon at https://www.amazon.com/Southwest-Slow-Cooking-Tammy-Biber/dp/0873588568/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=southwest+slow+cooking&sr=8-1.

-----------------------------------------------

RECIPE:

2.5 pounds of stew beef, cubed

All-purpose flour (enough to coat the meat)

2 tbsp olive oil

1 medium red onion, chopped

4 cloves garlic, chopped

1 jalapeño, seeded and chopped

1 serrano, seeded and chopped

2 15oz cans of garbanzo beans, rinsed

6 slices of smoked bacon, chopped

2 whole canned fire-roasted chiles, chopped

1.5 15oz cans of petite diced tomatoes

2 cups beef stock

1 tsp ground cumin

1 tsp Mexican oregano

1 tsp smoked salt

1/2 tsp black pepper

1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese

A pinch of dried basil

1. Toss the cubed stew beef in the flour and set aside. (*This can help the beef retain its juiciness as it slow cooks, but it can take a significant amount of time. Being that many cooks I've talked to have said they think it makes little difference in a recipe like this, I may skip this step next time and see if the effort is worth it.)

2. Add the oil to a pan and lightly brown the onion, garlic, jalapeño, and serrano.

3. After about 2 minutes, add the meat and continue to cook until the meat is lightly browned on all sides.

4. Add the browned meat mixture and all the remaining ingredients to the slow cooker, stir well, cover, and cook on low for 6-8 hours.

5. Spoon the soup into individual serving bowls and serve.

-----------------------------------------------

General Thoughts: I generally like slow cooker recipes because they are so easy! A few ingredients, some light prep, and a cooking process that couldn't be easier... But, this one was actually a bit more labor-intensive than I bargained for. There was a good bit of chopping (veggies, bacon, etc.), and the beef needed to be cubed and dredged in flour. Then the veggies needed to be sauteed and the beef browned before things even went into the slow cooker. Looking back at it, it was not as bad as some but, for a Crock-Pot recipe, it was more work than most, in my opinion.

*Pics 1 & 2 - Pictures from when I made it

The first thing that struck me was the color of this soup... For a recipe with "Green Chile" in the name, I expected it to be more... well... green. As you can see from the pics above, it is not that the soup's color was the least bit unappetizing or otherwise unusual, but it was a little surprising. The next thing that jumped out at me is that it turned out fairly bland. Again, not to say that it didn't have good general flavor, but it was almost devoid of the spicy heat I was hoping to get from this Green Chile soup, which included hot pepper on its ingredients list. I know better-than-most how much chiles can vary from crop to crop, but the hope is that they at least impart enough heat that you know they're in there.

With that said, however, the soup turned out pretty well. It was thick and hearty, exactly as a stew should be, and it would be great on a cool Fall night. The texture was fine and indicative of a nice, slow-cooked soup; the veggies and garbanzo beans were all perfectly tender. The meat was, likewise, tender and tasty, slow-cooked to perfection. I really enjoyed the garbanzo beans and love them as the starch in this soup. Truth be told, I found myself thinking I'd prefer them most times to potatoes in a soup like this, although I know that sentiment is not universally shared. In short, other than a lack of spiciness or a strong green chile taste, it was pretty good, especially after I added a pinch of salt to my bowl, so it is pretty solid, overall.

Potential Improvements? I'd love to try this one again with some additions/changes... First, I'd love to swap 1/2-cup of the beef broth for one cup of Mrs. Renfroe's Green Salsa (https://www.renfrofoods.com/products/green-salsa). This would have the effect of making the soup more "green" and give it that deeper green chile taste I craved while also helping to bump up the spice level. I would also like to pre-marinade the beef overnight (in my own meat marinade, combining ½ TBSP garlic salt, 1 TBSP cumin, 7 TBSP water, 1 TBSP liquid smoke, and 1 TBSP lime juice) and skip the dredging/browning exercise prior to adding the beef to the Crock-Pot.

Polling the Fam: Overall, I liked this one and would make it again, especially with the changes above. Becky thought it was fine and a solid beef stew but thought the garbanzo taste was too much. Jayson, likewise, liked it but added that he was not a garbanzo guy. Lisa thought it was fantastic but agreed it wasn't very spicy. Andrew thought it was pretty good and liked it, especially the meat. Hunter gave it high marks, calling it the best stew I've made as part of this project. And, Fox, thought it was "okay."

Verdict: Liked it. (4 stars)

Sunday Soup #118: Smokey Pumpkin Beer and Cheddar Potato Soup with Candied Bacon Popcorn

Happy Halloween, Booooo-per Troopers!! On the eve of my annual November social media hiatus, I wanted to give you something special... something unique... something seasonal. Love it or hate it, pumpkin is the official flavor of Fall and what many people think of as the year gets on toward Halloween and next month's food-focused holiday. Enter this "Smokey Pumpkin Beer and Cheddar Potato Soup with Candied Bacon Popcorn" (a soup with, what has to be, the longest name of any I've ever featured here). The recipe called out to me with its promise of creamy, spicy warmth. However, I have to admit to being initially wary of the featured ingredient. Those that know me know that I am not a huge fan of squash, in general, but this recipe seemed to elevate the pumpkin, so I committed to giving it a go. Let's see how it went...

This recipe came from: https://www.halfbakedharvest.com/smoky-pumpkin-beer-and-cheddar-potato-soup-with-candied-bacon-popcorn/

*Pic 1 - https://www.halfbakedharvest.com/smoky-pumpkin-beer-and-cheddar-potato-soup-with-candied-bacon-popcorn/

Variations from the Recipe as Written: Not exactly a variation, since the recipe called for me to use my favorite pumpkin beer, but I used an Elysian Dark O' The Moon stout (with notes of chocolate and cinnamon) because it was the only pumpkin brew I could get my hands on. I used regular (instead of low sodium) chicken broth. And, although the recipe called for air- or stove-popped popcorn, I used a plain microwave popcorn (only lightly salted) for convenience.

General Thoughts: The prep for this one took a bit, but I actually rather enjoyed it... Dicing the onion, peeling and dicing the potato, mincing the chiles, de-stemming the thyme, and shredding the cheese all took some time but didn't seem too bad, overall, and the cooking was pretty straightforward. Prepping the popcorn garnish took a bit more time and attention. Dicing the bacon, tossing with the pepitas and sugar, roasting, popping the popcorn, tossing all of it together again, roasting, tossing a final time, and roasting again, all while making sure nothing scorched, just required a bit of focus. The garnish mixture could be prepared ahead of time, particularly if you are able to keep the popcorn from getting soggy while it waits to be used.

*Pics 2 & 3 - Pictures from when I made it

My favorite thing about this soup was all of the fun textures. The creamy pumpkin was silky smooth, the diced potatoes and onions were perfectly soft, the chopped bacon was chewy, and the popcorn and pepitas provided a very interesting pseudo-crunch. The popcorn, in particular, held up surprisingly well and did not go all soggy or "wilt" when mixed into my bowl.

And, no doubt about it, this one tasted really good! The most forward flavors were sweet and spicy, but this recipe had a lot of depth. The pumpkin and candied bacon were rich and sweet, complemented by heavy cream, and the chiles in adobo imparted a terrific spicy zing to each bite. I used two chiles in adobo, which was perfect for me, but you may want to cut back to a single chile if you are making this dish for more sensitive eaters. The rich, smokey taste imparted by the bacon, the chiles in adobo, the smoked paprika, and the smoked cheeses was terrific. And, the thyme, curry powder, and beer flavors were all subtle but still managed to shine through in each bite. In short, this soup was a symphony of flavors, all wonderfully complimentary and none overpowering the others.

I can honestly say, this is the best pumpkin-based dish I think I have ever had in my life: tasty, sophisticated, and comforting!

Potential Improvements? I can't think of any way to improve this one, and I'd make it exactly the same way next time. As a variation, though, a few matchstick-sized slivers of granny smith apple added to your bowl would provide an additional texture and flavor that could (pleasantly) add to this soup's delightful complexity.

Polling the Fam: Everyone, including me (obviously), really enjoyed this one, and I think it will be a Fall/Winter staple in our house for many years to come!

Verdict: Loved it! (5 stars)

Sunday Soup #117: Creamy Asiago Chicken and Mushroom Tortellini Soup

Chicken, mushrooms, and tortellini with cheese and cream... What's not to love, right?! I picked this recipe up from Pinterest and found an opportunity to try it a couple of weeks ago with our besties (I know, I am tardy posting... sorry!), knowing they would like all the ingredients. I have to admit, I've had mixed results with tortellini soups, in the past; some have been really good (like this one: https://soupersleuth.blogspot.com/2019/08/sunday-soup-84-creamy-sausage-and.html) while others have left me a feeling a little "meh". It may be because I am not a huge Italian food or pasta fan, in general (I know, I know... I am an aberration), but I keep waiting for one to just knock my socks off! Would this be the one? Let's see...

This recipe came from: https://www.closetcooking.com/creamy-asiago-chicken-and-mushroom/

*Pic 1 - https://www.closetcooking.com/creamy-asiago-chicken-and-mushroom/

Variations from Recipe as Written: I doubled the recipe. That's it!

General Thoughts: This one was pretty much a piece of cake to prep! I used pre-sliced mushrooms, pre-diced onion, minced garlic, and grated cheese. Pretty much, the only prep work that took any real time was shredding the chicken. So, we started off in good shape!

*Pics 2 & 3 - Pictures from when I made it

But then... It just kind of fizzled. I mean, it was fine, I guess, but a recipe that seemed poised for greatness turned out to be just middle-of-the-road... unremarkable... unobjectionable. I am not sure you want to listen to me figure out how many more synonyms for 'okay' I can come up with, right? I think that is why I have been dragging my feet getting this one posted; I just wasn't that excited about it.

The textures were fine (although, the tortellini may have been a bit overdone), the soup had decent color, and it was certainly creamy, but it lacked a flavor identity. Each bite was fairly indistinguishable from the last, and I didn't feel like the garlic, thyme, white wine, or dijon mustard shined through enough to give it a distinct taste. My favorite ingredient was actually the mushrooms, which were tender but lacked any strong flavor of their own.

The bottom line with this one is that it was fine. It would not offend any of your guests, and it might even be a hit with those that prefer their fare on the blander side. But, it is likely not going to make anyone sit up and take notice or be a general crowd-pleaser.

Potential Improvements? If I ever make this one again, I am definitely going to add a bit of black pepper, give it a few shakes of crushed red pepper, and double (at least!) the dijon mustard. Anything to give the soup some more depth of flavor would be welcomed!

Polling the Fam: In case it was not already obvious, I thought this one was okay but was pretty "meh" about it. Becky found it bland, overall (though she thought the thyme was stronger than she liked), and said that she wanted the tortellini to be the star but that it just wasn't. Jayson didn't really like it, said it got worse as it cooled, and said the mushrooms were too big. Andrew found it "fine, middle-of-the-road," agreed with Jayson about the mushrooms, and said it was missing "something" but that he didn't know what. Hunter said it was fine, he liked the mushrooms, and that he'd eat it again. And, surprising no one, Fox said, "It was okay."

Verdict: It was okay. (3 stars)